See all reviews of Death of X (4)

Whether you’re a longtime X-Men fan (like myself) or a die-hard Cyclops fanatic (uh, like myself), you’re no doubt X-cited to read how Marvel Comics’ mutant revolutionary met his demise. Creators Jeff Lemire, Charles Soule and Aaron Kuder don’t get to Scott’s death in #1, but they do lay the groundwork for Cyclops’ last stand so well it has me wishing that creepy WikiLeaks guy would go and get me PDFs of the rest of Death of X instead of worrying about Hillary Clinton.

Death of X #1 (Marvel Comics)

death_of_x_1_cover

It wouldn’t be an X-Man story without complex continuity, right? So for those of you who aren’t caught up with the X-Men’s post-Secret Wars status quo, here are the CliffsNotes:

Toward the conclusion of Marvel’s Infinity event, the Inhumans’ leader Black Bolt detonated the Terrigen Bomb, which created the Terrigen Cloud that’s currently floating around the Earth. The Terrigen Mists are what give the Inhumans their powers, and transformations take place among seemingly ordinary humans (of Inhuman decent) whenever the Cloud rolls overhead. But whoops – turns out it kills mutants! Thanks, Black Bolt, no big deal – X-Men is just one of comics’ biggest franchises. What do you have to say for yourself?

NO, WAIT! DON’T SPEAK, BLACK BOLT, YOU’LL KILL US ALL!!!

Anyway, following the conclusion of Secret Wars, Marvel jumped ahead eight months to show us a world where mutants are close to extinction, Cyclops is dead and tensions between the Inhumans and the X-Men are X-tremely tense. So tense, in fact, they’ll need an entire event to work things out this December (Inhumans Vs. X-Men).

But how did we get to this point? That’s what Death of X promises to tell us. Lemire and Soule waste no time getting to the main event, as Cyclops and a squad of X-Men respond to a distress call from Muir Island. It’s there that Cyclops first learns the terrifying truth about the Terrigen Cloud. Horror film fans, take note – this is the X-Men comic for you. Eerie and suspenseful, thanks in large part to Kuder’s pencils – this is the X-Men facing a threat they can’t punch.

But if you’re looking for some old-school superheroics, you’ll be pleased to know the Inhuman portion of this debut issue is more colorful as they face off against classic Marvel foes. And why not? In terms of society accepting them, the Inhumans are in a pretty good place at the beginning of this story.

I will say, however, that this juxtaposition makes me despise the Inhumans. And I totally realize Nuhuman characters like Flint and Iso didn’t set off the Terrigen Bomb or ask for powers, but as an X-fan, I’d proudly wear a “Cyclops Was Right” T-shirt (if I owned one) as I read the rest of this series. I just feel like the Inhumans are a bit arrogant and I’d like to see them knocked down a peg…or off the shelves (I actually read Uncanny Inhumans regularly, so this is just the bitter X-fanboy in me talking).

death_of_x_1_kuder_wraparound_teaser_variant

But this does point to a bigger complaint I have with a lot of Marvel’s recent stories. I felt like in the original Civil War, the rift between hero factions was justified. But after Avengers Vs. X-Men, AXIS and now Civil War II, I have to wonder if Marvel is trying to make me despise half of their characters. I realize the world isn’t black and white, but if Marvel wants me to see people I’m supposed to like at each other’s throats, I can just scroll through my Facebook Newsfeed after a presidential debate.

On a creative front, if you’ve been happy with the work Lemire and Soule have been doing on Extraordinary X-Men and Uncanny Inhumans, respectively, you’ll be pleased with this prequel. While the writers are two of Marvel’s top talents, their writing is only enhanced by the fact we’re seeing Cyclops and Emma Frost in a comic book again after way too long of an absence.

And then there’s Kuder’s art. I had heard great things about the artist’s DC Comics work, and of course, there’s the recent news that Marvel signed him to an exclusive agreement. I’m happy to report he doesn’t disappoint. His is a detailed style reminiscent of artists Frank Quitely and Chris Burnham, and I look forward to Kuder’s future contributions to the House of Ideas. And, fingers crossed, on a post-IvX X-book.

Oh, I will say, there is a moment in this issue that’s sure to anger many mutant maniacs, so I’ll leave you with a sliver of good news – the next issue also ships this month!

After 50+ years spent battling megalomaniacal mutants, bigoted humans and killer robots, Lemire, Soule and Kuder prove that the X-Men’s greatest threat may just be a cloud – and the story’s so good, that’s okay.

Death of X #1 Review
Cyclops is back and in chargeSuspenseful storytelling and killer artSets the foundation for an epic clash between species
Is Marvel trying to make me hate the Inhumans?More X-Men, plz
10Fantastic
Reader Rating 2 Votes
5.1
  • Theycallme_Mick

    I feel like the hate towards Inhumans is entirely justified. I’m not sure why there is such a push to make them mainstream lately? Perhaps b/c Kevin Feige really wants an Inhumans movie made, I dunno. But for me, they’re a group of characters that just don’t land.

    They are essentially an X-Men rip off. And their existence makes no sense, not necessarily their history with the Kree, but just the fact that they represent the exact same thing as the X-Men (or mutants), yet get none of the shitstorm from the general public. Why would ordinary humans hate/fear mutants who are given gifts biologically, yet not hate the Inhumans who have powers as a result of genetics as well, and even released a bomb to purposefully turn people into Inhumans against their will?

    And that brings me to the biggest issue I have with this story. Are we, the reader, supposed to be torn over loyalty to either of these teams? Because I sure as hell do not agree with Inhumans on this. They purposefully set off a bomb to release a terrigen cloud that will fuck up people’s genetics, AGAINST THEIR WISHES. How are we as the reader supposed to be sympathetic to the Inhumans in any of this?

    X-Men all the way on this. I hope Cyclops takes out a few Inhumans on his way to the grave!

    • Chris Hassan

      I agree with several points here – especially how the Inhumans are pretty much the same as mutants, just don’t get the same level of disrespect from the general public. And last I heard, Feige wasn’t too keen on making that Inhumans movie, which is why it got pushed back on the film schedule. But we shall see…