Connect with us
Superman: Up in the Sky #5 Review

Comic Books

Superman: Up in the Sky #5 Review

This issue’s story continues the themes and characterization it set up in the first issue.

SPOILERS from here on out, fellow humans.

In terms of focus, issue #5 of Superman: Up in the Sky is far better than others in this series. Tom King slathers the Jesus allegories all over #5, putting the paragon of virtue in the moral hot-seat. Darkseid knows where the kidnapped girl is. But in order to save an innocent, Superman must kill an innocent.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

When he assists in a suicide, Superman comes back to Darkseid (blatantly called “the devil” here). Darkseid doesn’t believe him. So we cut to our next story where Superman is in an idyllic world where all is peaceful. We can tell even before the visual clues that this is some twisted scheme, which has been done to every superhero under the sun at this point in the 21st century (Spider-Man, Batman, Hulk, etc.). Of course, Superman declines, which is where we leave off.

While it has plenty of overwritten dialogue and predictable beats, at least this issue’s story continues the themes and characterization it set up in the first issue. We’ve only got one issue left to go and even King knows it’s time to focus and wrap this re-sold Walmart story up.

Andy Kubert’s art hasn’t been this good since #1. His best work conveys a scraggly texture, and every Up in the Sky location he envisions brims with detail. However, much of the atmosphere should also be attributed to the colorist, Brad Anderson. Apokalips is scabbed over with rock and streaming molten lava. The alien planet where Superman must assist in suicide is an eerily glowing place that envelops the struggling Man of Steel in ambiguous light. To convey the hopeful future Darkseid is feeding him, Metropolis gleams with radiant sunshine before the palette turns sickly green to show Superman’s actual imprisoned state.

Up in the Sky has certainly had its ups and downs, no better exemplified than in this thematically powerful but predictable installment.

Superman: Up in the Sky #5 Review
Superman: Up in the Sky #5
Is it good?
Up in the Sky has certainly had its ups and downs, no better exemplified than in this thematically powerful but predictable installment.
Andy Kubert and Brad Anderson's art.
Continues themes and characterization.
Predictable plotting.
Blunt dialogue that makes things too obvious.
6
AVERAGE

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today
Comments

In Case You Missed It

'My Adventures with Superman' gets new comics series starting June 2024 'My Adventures with Superman' gets new comics series starting June 2024

‘My Adventures with Superman’ gets new comics series starting June 2024

Comic Books

New DC Black Label 'Zatanna: Bring Down the House' out June 25th New DC Black Label 'Zatanna: Bring Down the House' out June 25th

New DC Black Label ‘Zatanna: Bring Down the House’ out June 25th

Comic Books

DC Preview: Action Comics #1063 DC Preview: Action Comics #1063

DC Preview: Action Comics #1063

Comic Books

Sink your teeth into new 'Blood Hunt' teeth series covers Sink your teeth into new 'Blood Hunt' teeth series covers

Sink your teeth into new ‘Blood Hunt’ teeth series covers

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup